A two-story house with blue-gray siding installed by Dagmar Pros.

Being a homeowner often means balancing the need for home improvements with the realities of budgeting. When you see your siding looking worn or weathered — thanks in part to our rainy Pacific Northwest climate — you might wonder whether it’s time for a full replacement or if a fresh coat of paint will suffice.

It’s a big decision that depends on the overall state of your siding and your financial flexibility. Our goal here isn’t to push you one way or the other; it’s to lay out the facts so you can make the choice that works best for your home.

Pros and Cons of Repainting Your Siding

Pros

Cost-Effective: Painting is less expensive than replacing your siding, so it’s much more appealing if you’re working with a tight budget.
Instant Curb Appeal: A new paint job can usually be finished faster than a full siding installation. That fresh coat of paint breathes new life into your home’s exterior, giving it a clean, updated look.
Color Flexibility: Whether you want to stick with a classic hue or try something new, repainting offers an easy way to switch up your home’s style.
Extra Layer of Protection: High-quality paint protects against moisture, sun exposure, and other elements.
Minimal Disruption: Compared to siding replacement, painting involves less noise, dust, and mess.

Cons

Only Surface-Level Solutions: Painting doesn’t fix underlying problems — like rotting or damaged materials. If those deeper issues are present, you’ll need to replace your siding sooner rather than later.
Ongoing Maintenance: Even the most durable paint can peel or fade in our wet climate, so you may need to repaint again if you want that sparkling fresh appearance.
No Energy Efficiency Gains: A paint job won’t improve insulation, so you won’t see any energy savings.
Potential Hidden Damage: Make sure you get a proper inspection before repainting your siding. Otherwise, you might paint over deteriorating siding, which can lead to repeat (and more expensive) repairs.

Pros and Cons of Replacing Your Siding

Pros

Better Long-Term Investment: If your siding is in rough shape, replacement may be more cost-effective over time by reducing frequent repairs or repeated paint jobs.
Upgrade Opportunity: Modern siding materials are better at insulation, offer improved durability, and provide superior weather resistance.
Increased Home Value: Fresh siding can raise your home’s market appeal, helping it stand out if you decide to sell.
Options and Aesthetics: Your new siding will give you a wide array of stylish, durable options to choose from.
Warranty Protection: Many new siding materials include warranties that cover common issues like fading or warping, giving you peace of mind about future repairs.

Cons

Higher Initial Cost: The upfront expense of replacing siding can be a challenge if you’re on a tight budget.
Longer Project Timeline: Siding replacement involves more steps — removal, possible repairs, and new installation — which extends the overall duration.
Project Disruptions: Between the noise and the crew, be prepared for a temporary change in your daily routine.

How Much Does It Cost to Replace Siding?

We know cost is the biggest factor for many homeowners considering new siding. Here are the key elements that influence how much you’ll pay — and why:

Home Size and Layout: The larger or more complex your home’s exterior, the more materials and labor are required.
Siding Material: Do your homework on the best siding material for your needs. Each has its own price point, maintenance needs, and lifespan.
Labor and Installation: Highly skilled, experienced installers might cost more up front, but they save you from costly mistakes down the road.
Repairs: Any existing damage or required upgrades (such as adding insulation) may increase the overall cost.
Trim and Finishing Touches: Decorative or custom trim work can raise costs, but also add style.
Project Complexity: Multi-story homes, unique architectural details, or challenging access points typically come with higher labor costs.

The Final Verdict: Should You Repaint or Replace Your Siding?

Before you make your final decision, we recommend having a professional contractor look over your siding. They can give you an accurate picture of the condition of your siding, which can help pinpoint the right solution for your specific needs.

Repaint If: Your current siding is in relatively good shape, and you want an affordable way to freshen up your home’s look. Be prepared for regular maintenance to keep your exterior looking sharp.
Replace If: You’re dealing with significant damage, worried about insulation, or want to invest in a long-term solution that boosts both your home’s aesthetics and value.

Get Started with a Free Estimate

We understand that new siding is an investment — both in time and money. That’s why our team is here to help you decide the best path forward.

Ready to explore your options? Contact us today for a free quote on your siding replacement, and let’s find the best solution for your home.

Back to Siding